31 Best Cookie Exchange Recipes Everyone Will Love (2024)

Spread the joy and sweetness to your loved ones this Christmas with our list of over 30 Best Cookie Exchange Recipes.

Holiday cookies are great as treats, gifts, and snacks, and you could make them as presents or hold a cookie decorating contest.

They are perfect for any occasion!

Try these delicious recipes from chocolate cookies to gingerbread cookies to sugar cookies and everything in between!

So preheat your oven and start baking! I’m sure your kids will love them!

PIN THIS FOR LATER!31 Best Cookie Exchange Recipes Everyone Will Love (1)

This post contains affiliate links. For more information, see my disclosureshere.

Irresistible Cookie Exchange Recipes

1. Cake Batter Chocolate Chip Cookies

31 Best Cookie Exchange Recipes Everyone Will Love (2)

Get the full recipe on Sally’s Baking Addiction

These chocolate chip cookies made with cake batter are a combination of soft-baked chocolate chip cookies and sprinkle-filled cake.

This is Sally’s Baking Addiction’s most popular cookie recipe, and after baking a batch, you’ll see why.

You’ll adore these quirky cookies if you like chocolate chip cookies and sneaking a taste of cake batter.

2. Gingerbread Cookies (cookie exchange recipes)

31 Best Cookie Exchange Recipes Everyone Will Love (3)

Get the full recipe on Cooking Classy

This is my favorite recipe for Gingerbread Cookies!

It produces deliciously soft and chewy cookies with just the proper amount of spices and molasses flavor.

The dough is simple to work with, and decorating them is a lot of fun. These are sure to become one of your new favorite Christmas cookies!

3. The Best Sugar Cookies EVER (according to my MIL)

31 Best Cookie Exchange Recipes Everyone Will Love (4)

Get the full recipe on It’s Fitting

The cookies are delicate and buttery, and they’re nearly like shortbread in that they’re not too sweet to be drenched in royal icing.

Because a cookie isn’t a cookie unless it’s been drenched in insanely delicious frosting.

4. Chocolate Dipped Cheesecake Cookies (cookie exchange recipes)

31 Best Cookie Exchange Recipes Everyone Will Love (5)

Get the full recipe on Yellow Bliass Road

These creamy and delicate Cheesecake Cookies are a must-try!

It’s a delectable cookie recipe that’s not overly sweet yet completely addicting!

5. Peppermint Meltaway Cookies

31 Best Cookie Exchange Recipes Everyone Will Love (6)

Get the full recipe onCooking Classy

The buttery, pepperminty flavor of these cookies is to die for.

As if that weren’t enough, these are topped with a sweet, delectable peppermint frosting and tiny crushed peppermint bits.

It’s the kind of cookie you’ll fantasize about.

6. Red Velvet Gooey Butter Cookies (cookie exchange recipes)

31 Best Cookie Exchange Recipes Everyone Will Love (7)

Get the full recipe on Chef in Training

Are you one of those Red Velvet lovers? We can’t get enough of this trending red velvet, especially during Christmas and Valentine’s Day.

So you need to try this soft and moist cookie version!

7.Buckeye Balls (Peanut Butter Balls)

31 Best Cookie Exchange Recipes Everyone Will Love (8)

Get the full recipe on Dinner at the Zoo

Looks so inviting! Peanut butter is my all-time favorite!

So I’d be truly happy if someone gifted me these rich and creamy Buckeye Balls!

8. Turtle Cookies (cookie exchange recipes)

31 Best Cookie Exchange Recipes Everyone Will Love (9)

Get the full recipe on Tastes Better from Scratch

I could almost taste these Turtle cookies just by looking at them.

The caramel got me! This amazing recipe is definitely on my list!

9. Cranberry Orange Cookies

31 Best Cookie Exchange Recipes Everyone Will Love (10)

Get the full recipe on Let’s Dish

You only need 25 minutes to make these soft and chewy Cranberry Orange cookies.

The ingredients are also simple but will turn out to be awesome and a crowd-pleaser!

10. Perfect Apple Pie Cookies

31 Best Cookie Exchange Recipes Everyone Will Love (11)

Get the full recipe on Oh My Goodness Chocolate Desserts

Alright, I can’t get enough of caramel here! I love, love everything about these sticky and chewy, bite-sized caramel apple pies!

11.Peanut Butter Kiss Cookies Recipe

31 Best Cookie Exchange Recipes Everyone Will Love (12)

Get the full recipe on Eating on a Dime

Another creamy peanut butter cookie recipe here with Hershey’s Kisses as a bonus! What not to love?

12.Double Chocolate Cherry Cookie

31 Best Cookie Exchange Recipes Everyone Will Love (13)

Get the full recipe on Small Town Woman

What a gorgeous sweet treat we have here!

These Double Chocolate Cherry Cookies are soft with a maraschino cherry in the middle and then drizzled with a chocolate fudge sauce.

I can’t wait to make them!

13.Kris Kringle Crinkles

31 Best Cookie Exchange Recipes Everyone Will Love (14)

Get the full recipe on Two Sisters

Another favorite of mine! These Kris Kringle Crinkles look sooo Christmassy.

I love the colors plus they’re light and fluffy on the inside and sweet and crunchy on the outside.

14.Holiday Nuggets

31 Best Cookie Exchange Recipes Everyone Will Love (15)

Get the full recipe on Recipe Girl

This special Holiday Nuggets cookie recipe has been the author’s family tradition for over 40 years.

That really says a lot about this cookie. And I’d love to try them too!

15. Meltaway Christmas Cookies (cookie exchange recipes)

31 Best Cookie Exchange Recipes Everyone Will Love (16)

Get the full recipe on Give Recipe

Now, this one’s super cute! These Meltaway Christmas Cookies will make the best edible gift this holiday.

They’re also so easy to make (less than 30 minutes) and only require simple ingredients that will melt in your mouth, literally!

16. Andes Mint Cookies

31 Best Cookie Exchange Recipes Everyone Will Love (17)

Get the full recipe on Chocolate With Grace

Soft-baked chocolate cookie loaded with Andes Mint pieces and spread with an extra layer of mint goodness.

What more could you ask for? These Andes Mint cookies are amazing!

17.Peppermint White Chocolate Cookies

31 Best Cookie Exchange Recipes Everyone Will Love (18)

Get the full recipe on Sally’s Baking Addiction

Here’s another winning cookie recipe from Sally’s Baking Addiction.

These Peppermint White Chocolate cookies are what you need!

They are soft, chewy, and look festive, delicious, and easy!

18. Apricot Kolaches – A Traditional Hungarian Christmas Cookie

31 Best Cookie Exchange Recipes Everyone Will Love (19)

Get the full recipe on American Heritage Cooking

With just the right amount of sweetness and crispiness, these Apricot Kolaches are totally addicting!

19. S’mores Cookies (cookie exchange recipes)

31 Best Cookie Exchange Recipes Everyone Will Love (20)

Get the full recipe on Dessert Now Dinner Later

S’mores lovers, you’re going to love these tasty and amazing S’mores Cookies!

With lots of good comments on this recipe, it’s definitely a must-try!

20.Maraschino Cherry Chocolate Chip Cookies

31 Best Cookie Exchange Recipes Everyone Will Love (21)

Get the full recipe on The First Year

Absolutely appealing! This thick and chewy maraschino cherry chocolate chip cookie is love!

I can’t wait to have a bite!

21. Chocolate Mint Cookies

31 Best Cookie Exchange Recipes Everyone Will Love (22)

Get the full recipe on Butter With A Side of Bread

Simply irresistible Chocolate Mint Cookies that not only look festive but taste great as well! Perfect for any holiday!

22. Soft And Lemony Ricotta Cookies (cookie exchange recipes)

31 Best Cookie Exchange Recipes Everyone Will Love (23)

Get the full recipe on Just a Little Bit of Bacon

Soft and tender Ricotta cookies topped with a lemon glaze plus colorful sprinkles!

These traditional Italian cookies are perfect for Christmas, Easter, and any other holiday or occasion.

23. Chocolate Dipped Sugar Cookies

31 Best Cookie Exchange Recipes Everyone Will Love (24)

Get the full recipe on Mom Luck

These Chocolate Dipped Sugar Cookies look so much fun, are easy to make, and taste delicious!

24. M&M’s Christmas Cookie Bars

31 Best Cookie Exchange Recipes Everyone Will Love (25)

Get the full recipe on No. 2 Pencil

Who doesn’t love M&M’s? This is such a great idea to put them in cookie bars! I’m sure it’ll be a hit for your kids!

25.Best Fudgy Chewy Chocolate Brownie Cookies

31 Best Cookie Exchange Recipes Everyone Will Love (26)

Get the full recipe on House of Nash Eats

Ok, lovelies here’s the best fudgy chewy chocolate brownie cookies in town!

I love the chocolate chips, chopped walnuts, and the idea that you’re eating brownies in cookie form!

26. Peppermint Meltaway Cookies (cookie exchange recipes)

31 Best Cookie Exchange Recipes Everyone Will Love (27)

Get the full recipe on Cakes Cottage

Beautiful Peppermint Meltaway Cookies that you just can’t stop eating!

These Peppermint MeltAway Cookies are simple to make and, as the name implies, melt in your mouth!

Basically, it is a near relative of the famous MeltAway Cookie that is “a little more festive,” making it a lovely Christmas cookie that will undoubtedly make your Christmas cookie tray appear merry.

27.Chocolate Mint Crinkles

31 Best Cookie Exchange Recipes Everyone Will Love (28)

Get the full recipe on Betty Crocker

Oh my, these Chocolate Mint Crinkles are sooo pretty and taste wonderful! You really need to try this!

These homemade crinkles are topped with peppermint Hershey’s Kisses and are a great complement to your holiday cookie exchange presentation!

28. Chocolate Kiss Cookies

31 Best Cookie Exchange Recipes Everyone Will Love (29)

Get the full recipe on Baked by Rachel

Calling all chocolate lovers! These Chocolate kiss cookies might be your ultimate cookie this holiday season!

It has a super chocolatey center and crisp sugary coating…need I say more?

29. Oreo Balls (cookie exchange recipes)

31 Best Cookie Exchange Recipes Everyone Will Love (30)

Get the full recipe on Pip and Ebby

If you’re looking for a no-bake, super easy dessert that’s perfect for the holidays, then definitely try these 3-ingredient Oreo balls!

30.Grandma’s Perfect Jam Thumbprint Cookies

31 Best Cookie Exchange Recipes Everyone Will Love (31)

Get the full recipe on Wicked Good Kitchen

These thumbprint cookies look really delish! The soft, sweet interiors and jam-filled centers make you want some more!

31. Sprinkle Snowball Cookies (best cookie exchange recipes)

31 Best Cookie Exchange Recipes Everyone Will Love (32)

Get the full recipe on Katrina’s Kitchen

A nut-free Sprinkle Snowball Cookies that your kids will surely enjoy during classroom parties, holidays, or Christmas cookie exchange!

31 Best Cookie Exchange Recipes Everyone Will Love (33)

Print Recipe

5 from 7 votes

31 Best Cookie Exchange Recipes Everyone Will Love

Spread the joy and sweetness to your loved ones this Christmas with our list of over 30 Best Cookie Exchange Recipes. Try these delicious recipes from chocolate cookies to gingerbread cookies to sugar cookies and everything in between!

Course: Dessert

Cuisine: American

Keyword: best cookie exchange recipes, christmas cookie exchange, christmas cookie exchange ideas, cookie exchange ideas, cookie exchange recipes, cookie swap ideas, cookie swap recipes, easy christmas cookies for cookie exchange, ideas for christmas cookie exchange, super easy cookie exchange recipes

Author: The Sharp Aspirant

Ingredients

  • all-purpose flour
  • baking soda
  • unsalted butter
  • granulated sugar
  • pure vanilla extract
  • chocolate chips
  • sprinkles
  • ground cinnamon
  • ground nutmeg
  • baking powder
  • baking soda
  • vanilla
  • flour
  • baking powder
  • salt
  • eggs
  • butter
  • full fat cream cheese
  • powdered sugar
  • cornstarch
  • peppermint extract
  • unsweetened cocoa powder
  • red liquid food coloring
  • creamy peanut butter
  • chocolate chips
  • candy melts
  • vegetable shortening
  • holiday sprinkles
  • regular caramels
  • grated orange zest
  • dried cranberries

Instructions

  • Select your choice of Cookie Exchange Recipes from the article.

  • Click on the link to get the full recipes and instructions.

  • Get ready to prep, cook, and enjoy!

Video

More Awesome Articles You’ll Love:

  • 12 Best Keto Cookie Recipes
  • 12 Easy Christmas Treat Recipes
  • 21+ Easy Christmas co*cktails 2023
  • 15 Best Thanksgiving Cookie Recipes
  • 17 Green Desserts For St Patrick’s Day!
  • 21 DIY Christmas Wreaths to Make Now!
  • 21 Best Christmas Cookie Recipes for 2021
  • 12 Best Christmas Dessert Recipes for 2021
  • 20 Delicious Christmas Lunch Ideas You Can Meal Prep
  • 12 Mother’s Day Cookies That Are Sure to Make Her Day
  • Christmas Decor Ideas That Are Perfect for Small Spaces
  • 12 Christmas Snack Ideas Perfect for Holiday Gatherings
  • 41+ Kid-friendly DIY Christmas Crafts You Need To Try Now!

If you find this article useful, please share it on Facebook or Pinterest. Thank you for visiting Sharp Aspirant!

31 Best Cookie Exchange Recipes Everyone Will Love (34)

Follow us onPINTERESTfor more cookie exchange recipes!

31 Best Cookie Exchange Recipes Everyone Will Love (2024)

References

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Allyn Kozey

Last Updated:

Views: 5456

Rating: 4.2 / 5 (43 voted)

Reviews: 90% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Allyn Kozey

Birthday: 1993-12-21

Address: Suite 454 40343 Larson Union, Port Melia, TX 16164

Phone: +2456904400762

Job: Investor Administrator

Hobby: Sketching, Puzzles, Pet, Mountaineering, Skydiving, Dowsing, Sports

Introduction: My name is Allyn Kozey, I am a outstanding, colorful, adventurous, encouraging, zealous, tender, helpful person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.